Murder: The Third Voice, BBC2, Morven Christie

Murder: The Third Voice (No. 1) DS Evans (Morven Christie) - (C) ©Touchpaper Television Ltd - Photographer: Anne Binckebanck

Coming to grief: DS Evans (Morven Christie)

A compelling and distinctive crime series in which the characters talk directly to the audience

★★★★ BBC2, Thursday, 3 March, 9pm

THIS SHORT SERIES is unlike any other crime saga currently on the box. The characters don’t talk to each other, they talk to you about their involvement in a tragic case, breaking the imaginary fourth wall and relaying their frustrations, justifications and heartache.

What’s going on? That’s for you to decide as the accounts unfold. It’s an impressionistic and fluid exploration of events before and after a murder, and it is engrossing.

The Scottish setting of the first story, The Third Voice, is also beautifully filmed, with The Killing‘s director Birger Larsen at the helm. He also directed 2012’s excellent Murder: Joint Enterprise, which had a similar format.

The story is knotty – Rafe Carey and his brother-in-law Leo Durridge go fishing on the River Tweed. In what first appears to be a tragic accident, Rage ends up dead after the section of riverbank they were on is washed away in heavy rain.

Murder - TX: 03/03/2016 - Episode: The Third Voice (No. 1) - Picture Shows: The river Tweed - (C) Touchpaper Television Limited - Photographer: Touchpaper Television Limited

Stunning setting: The River Tweed

Morven Christie as Sgt Evans

Except that Rafe is found by Sgt Corrine Evans’s team to have a stab wound. He was dead before he ended up in the water. Further complications arise when a witness reports hearing the voices of three men during the confrontation.

We also learn that Rafe (Frank Gilhooley) and Leo (Peter McDonald) had gone on the trip after Leo’s daughter Sonia died of meningitis while being looked after by Rafe and his wife. The fishing trip was supposed to be a chance to rebuild their relationship. [Read more…]

Murder: Joint Enterprise, BBC2, starring Karla Crome and Robert Pugh PREVIEW

BBC2 Joe Dempsie, Karla Crome
Stefan and Coleen – did they act together in killing Erin? Pics: BBC

Rating: ★★★★½ 

BBC2: Sunday, 26 August, 10pm

Story: A woman lies dead in a Nottingham flat, her terrified sister barricaded in the bathroom. At 2am a young man in a bloodstained shirt is pulled over for speeding. The three only met that afternoon – what happened in those fatal hours? All there is to go on is what the two survivors say.

Birger Larsen, who called the shots on The Killing, came to the UK to direct this documentary-style murder drama that is bold, messy and totally compelling.

The hour-long narrative delving into the death of Erin at the Nottingham flat she shared with her sister, Coleen, is fragmentary, told to camera by those involved in the case in conflicting and self-serving statements. as well as in flashbacks, CCTV footage, family snapshots and evidence photos.

Erin is killed with an Amaretto bottle
It’s messy because real life is messy, and the script by Robert Jones resoundingly exposes the fallacy of most TV crime shows with their neat denouements. Murder: Joint Enterprise taxes the viewer by forcing you to try to locate the truth in what unfolds.

BBC2 Stephen Dillane
Raglin, the prosecution QC outlines his tactics

At first, it seems clear cut. Erin and Coleen are out at a snooker hall when they meet Stefan, who barges his way back to their flat. Coleen says she felt threatened by the pushy young man and that he killed Erin while she was locked in the bathroom. Stefan is arrested later that evening while driving Erin’s car, and has her blood on him. Erin was battered with an Amaretto bottle.

The case is not as clear as it first appears
But by day two of the investigation, the story shifts. Erin and Coleen, abandoned nine years before by their mother, often fought. Was there some sexual rivalry between the sisters with Stefan back at the flat. What was the role of Coleen’s boyfriend, Heskett Jupp, in what happened.

And while Stefan admits he’s ‘done stuff’, he denies murder. The past histories of Stefan and the sisters clearly impacts on their present day lives and hang-ups, and Robert Jones’s script – which he says was the hardest he’s ever written – sensitively explores their backgrounds, particularly the trauma caused by the sisters being deserted by their mother.

Coleen says of the time after she was taken into care, ‘There’s something about being locked out of your own flat and looking in. It’s like being dead.’

Claire Rushbrook
Claire Rushbrook as mum Ellen

We only briefly see the characters interacting, and that’s a CCTV glimpse of Coleen and her mother. But the truth slowly comes into focus as the twisting trial of Stefan and Coleen proceeds and then a final revealing flashback gives us the full, disconcerting picture.

It’s a haunting, atmospheric and affecting hour, brilliantly acted and directed. And unlike most mainstream dramas, it packs an ending that sticks in your mind for some time after. Terrific.

Cast: Karla Crome Coleen, Joe Dempsie Stefan, Stephen Dillane Raglin, Robert Pugh DI Sheehy, Claire Rushbrook Ellen, Lara Rossi Erin, Darren Campbell Heskett Jupp, Lauren Socha Deena, Kate Donnelly Pathologist

 Follow @crimetimeprev

%d bloggers like this: